• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to footer
StockM logo. Inventoy management system

StockM

Atsargų valdymo sistema

  • StockM solution
    • Wholesale & Distribution
    • Manufacturing
    • Retail & Perishable Goods
  • Company
  • Calculator
  • News
  • Partners
  • Clients
  • Recommendations
  • Contacts
  • EN
    • LT

Lower margin or faster turnover? A practical financial dilemma

2026-11-18

The answer depends on how much gross profit each dollar invested in stock earns. A discount speeds up turnover only when sales grow enough to make up for the margin you give away. The other route is to speed up turnover without touching the price: stop ordering stock you don’t need to cover actual consumption and replenishment time. Turnover improves, and the margin stays where it was.

A discount is still the right call when you’ve already bought too much, and the goods won’t sell on their own. At that point, the question is no longer “margin or turnover”. It’s how much money you can still recover, and how quickly.

This article continues our series:

  • Inventory and working capital: is inventory an investment for a business?
  • Where does working capital get tied up in inventory?
  • How does managing inventory with dynamic buffers help release cash tied up in stock?
  • What are the most important inventory management KPIs?

Where does the dilemma of margin and turnover come from?

Most business owners know the situation. Cash is short, the warehouse is full, and finance wants inventory turnover to go up. The commercial team suggests the obvious fix: cut prices, run a promotion, clear out the stock. At the same time, purchasing argues that a bigger order with a supplier discount will improve the margin. Both arguments sound reasonable, but they pull in opposite directions.

One side wants to protect the profit on every unit sold. The other wants to protect the speed at which money comes back out of stock. To choose between them, you need a measure that captures both at once.

How are margin and turnover linked financially?

First, the terms. Gross profit margin is gross profit divided by sales revenue. ACCA calculates it like this (ACCA, Ratio analysis):

Gross profit margin = gross profit ÷ sales revenue × 100%

It’s important to keep margin and markup apart. Both are worked out from the same gross profit, just divided by different amounts. Say a product costs $60 and sells for $100. That leaves $40 of gross profit per unit.

Margin (on the selling price) = $40 ÷ $100 x 100% = 40%

Markup (on cost) = $40 ÷ $60 x 100% = 66.7%

The same $40 looks like two different numbers, so when purchasing talks about markup and finance talks about margin, they end up talking past each other, and their figures can’t be compared. Every formula in the rest of this article uses margin. If you plugged in markup instead, you’d get the wrong answer. For example, when working out how much more you need to sell after a 10% discount, a 40% margin gives +33%, but a 66.7% markup entered by mistake gives only +18%. The discount would look far easier to pay back than it really is.

Inventory turnover shows how quickly the money invested in stock comes back through sales. Expressed in days, it’s calculated like this (ACCA, Ratio analysis):

Inventory days = inventory ÷ cost of goods sold × 365

In financial analysis, a company’s return on capital is split into two parts: operating profit margin and asset turnover (ACCA, Ratio analysis). Put simply, your return depends on how much you earn on each sale and how many times a year the same money goes round.

ACCA gives this illustration: a 5% margin and an asset turnover of 2. That means every $100 of sales leaves $5 of profit, and every $100 invested generates $200 of sales a year. So $100 invested earns 2 × $5 = $10 a year, a 10% return. A 10% margin would give the same 10% return if the money went around only once a year. In other words, a lower margin can only be made up for by money turning over faster.

For inventory, the same logic is captured by GMROI (Gross Margin Return on Inventory Investment). It shows how much gross profit a company earns for every dollar invested in stock (Shopify, GMROI):

GMROI = gross profit ÷ average inventory at cost

The formula can be split into two parts:

GMROI = (gross profit ÷ sales) × (sales ÷ average inventory at cost)

GMROI = margin × inventory turnover on sales

When you cut the price, the first factor goes down. For GMROI not to fall, the second has to rise by more. The fact that turnover has improved tells you nothing about profit on its own.

How much do sales need to grow for a discount to pay off?

Before announcing a discount, it’s worth doing one calculation. If the price is cut by a given percentage, the increase in volume needed to keep gross profit the same is:

Required volume increase = price cut % ÷ (margin % − price cut %)

Current marginDiscountHow much more you need to sell
40%5%+14%
40%10%+33%
25%10%+67%
20%10%+100%

The calculation assumes the unit cost doesn’t change and the discount applies to the whole volume sold.

The lower the margin, the harder it is to pay for a discount with extra turnover. In wholesale and distribution, where margins are often thin, even a small discount needs a very large jump in sales. Whether that jump happens depends on how price-sensitive buyers are, on competitors, and on whether customers simply hold off until the next promotion.

Can you speed up turnover without cutting the margin?

Yes, and it’s often the cheaper route. Inventory turnover depends not only on how much you sell, but also on how much stock you hold. If sales stay the same and average inventory halves, turnover doubles and the margin doesn’t change.
As we wrote in Where does working capital get tied up in inventory?, overstock rarely builds up because of one big mistake. It comes from lots of small decisions: demand fell but replenishment carried on; safety stock stayed after the reason for it had gone; a supplier’s minimum order quantity or discount encouraged a bigger purchase; temporary stock became permanent. Each of these slows turnover, and later it seems the only way to speed it up again is a discount.
In TOC inventory management, every product at every location has a buffer: as much stock as is needed to cover actual consumption over the order cycle and the replenishment lead time (StockM, TOC buffer zones). On each ordering day, you order only what’s needed to top the buffer back up. Anything above the buffer simply isn’t reordered, and it turns back into cash through normal sales at the normal price. Dynamic Buffer Management (DBM) keeps these levels under review: if a product sits in the green zone for a long time, its buffer comes down; if it keeps dropping into the red zone, the buffer goes up.
That doesn’t remove the need for discounts. It changes their role: a discount becomes a tool for exceptions, not a standing way of correcting inventory mistakes.

When is a lower margin the right choice after all?

There are situations where cash today is worth more than margin tomorrow. The key is to recognize them and not to confuse them with routine replenishment.

  1. Slow-moving and non-moving goods. If a product has stopped selling, its cost is money already spent. The decision isn’t about what you paid for it, but about how much you can still recover and how quickly. The longer you wait, the less you can recover, while storage and handling costs keep adding up.
  2. Short shelf-life goods. Whatever isn’t sold before its expiry date is written off. A discount applied in time often means a smaller loss than a write-off.
  3. End of season and assortment exits. Once a season is over or a product is discontinued, the remaining stock may be worth much less next year, or nothing at all.
  4. A realistic, tested assumption about price sensitivity. Sometimes a discount really does lift sales enough. In that case, plan it as a promotion: with a goal, a start and end date, and a review afterwards.

How do you present the margin vs turnover choice to the board?

We covered the general financial points about inventory KPIs, such as why released cash comes back only once, in What are the most important inventory management KPIs?. Here we add three points that are specific to the choice between margin and turnover.

  • Compare dollars, not percentages. Margin and turnover often move in opposite directions, so each of them on its own can show an “improvement”. Base the decision on gross profit in dollars and on GMROI. In the example below, those are the figures that show which route actually earns more.
  • Convert a supplier discount into days in the warehouse. A discount for a larger quantity raises the margin per unit, but the extra goods sit in the warehouse for longer. Compare the discount in dollars with the extra inventory days it creates and what it costs you to hold that money: storage, financing, and the risk that some of the goods won’t sell.
  • Count the sales you miss at full price, too. The need for discounts often comes in a pair: overstock sits in the warehouse while best sellers are out of stock. When a product isn’t there, some full-price sales don’t happen or are put off. Cash released from overstock and moved into these products earns the full margin, not a reduced one.

Hypothetical example

The figures below are made up to show the calculation. This is not a client case. We assume the unit cost doesn’t change, storage costs are left out, and in scenario B the availability of the most important products stays the same.

A wholesale company sells a product with a unit cost of $60 and a selling price of $100. It sells 1,200 units a year. On average it holds 400 units in the warehouse, because the team habitually orders in large quantities. Finance asks for better turnover, and two routes are on the table.

  • Scenario A: discount. The price is cut by 10%, to $90. We assume sales rise by 20%, to 1,440 units, and ordering habits stay the same, so average stock remains at 400 units.
  • Scenario B: stock managed by buffer. The price stays the same. Only what’s needed to top up the buffer is ordered. We assume average stock falls to 200 units and sales stay at 1,200 units.
Measure (per year)Current situation: price $100Scenario A: sold at $90 all year (10% off)Scenario B: price $100, stock managed by buffer
Units sold per year1,2001,4401,200
Sales revenue$120,000$129,600$120,000
Cost of goods sold$72,000$86,400$72,000
Gross profit$48,000$43,200$48,000
Gross profit margin40%33.3%40%
Average inventory (at cost)$24,000$24,000$12,000
Inventory days12210161
GMROI2.01.84.0

Inventory days = average inventory ÷ cost of goods sold × 365. GMROI = gross profit ÷ average inventory at cost.

In scenario A, turnover improves: inventory days fall from 122 to 101. In a report, that would look like a success. But gross profit drops by $4,800, and GMROI falls from 2.0 to 1.8. To keep gross profit the same, the company would need to sell 1,600 units, a third more than now, not 20% more.

In scenario B, inventory days fall to 61, the margin is unchanged, and GMROI doubles. On top of that, once stock settles at the buffer level, the company recovers around $12,000 that was previously tied up in the warehouse, as a one-off. This cash comes back gradually, through normal sales, not all at once.

Now suppose the warehouse also holds 300 units of another product that has almost stopped selling. Their cost is $18,000. Sold at $70 each, they would bring back $21,000 and earn $3,000 of gross profit. If they can realistically be sold only at $50, the company would recover $15,000 in cash but book a $3,000 loss. In this case a lower margin, even a negative one, can be the right decision, because the alternative is to wait and recover even less. What matters is making it clear to management that this is cash recovery, not profit growth.

Both cases point the same way. Speed up turnover on good sellers by cutting overstock, and save discounts for the products that won’t move without them.

How does this work in StockM?

StockM is an assortment and inventory management system built on TOC and Dynamic Buffer Management. Every product at every location is given a buffer that is adjusted to actual consumption, and on ordering day the system suggests the quantity needed to top the buffer up (StockM, Buffer-based inventory management). That way, overstock of good sellers comes down through normal sales, without changing the price.

Other features are directly linked to the balance between margin and turnover (StockM, Wholesale and distribution):

  • Supplier terms. Minimum order quantities, minimum order values, and delivery schedules can be set for each supplier individually, and purchase orders are built around these requirements. This shows where a buffer is being driven up by supplier terms rather than by demand.
  • Promotions and seasons. Buffers are raised temporarily for promotions and seasons, then returned to their previous level when the period ends. This stops promotional stock from lingering unnoticed in the warehouse. As we explain in TOC or forecasting, forecasts and commercial plans are needed when preparing for a promotion, but the outcome should be judged against actual consumption.
  • Assortment exits. Buffers for products being discontinued are reduced gradually, and reports help sell off the remaining stock in an orderly way.
  • Turnover reports. The system automatically produces SKU turnover reports, ABC analysis, and non-mover alerts, so non-moving products that may need a discount are spotted earlier.

StockM doesn’t make pricing decisions for the company. The system shows where stock exceeds what’s needed and which products have stopped moving, and the commercial and finance teams decide on any discount. The outcome also depends on data quality and on how the team acts on these signals.

StockM client: home, garden and yard tools retailer

The client’s name is not disclosed, and no figures are published.

The client sells home, garden and yard tools through three physical stores and an online store. Competition in this sector is fierce, so the company sourced most of its products from distant but cheaper suppliers. That was how it protected its margin.

This strategy came at a price. Because deliveries took several months, orders were large and inventory turnover was low. More importantly, the company couldn’t react quickly to changes in demand: if a product started selling better than expected, the next order would only arrive months later. Most of its customers were regulars, and if they couldn’t find what they needed, it was easy for them to go to competitors, namely the big retail chains.

After listening carefully to the challenges the company’s owners described and analyzing the state of its stock, we decided to change its supplier selection policy. Instead of distant, cheap suppliers, the company began to focus on more expensive but closer ones that could fulfill orders within one or two weeks.

The product margin did fall, of course. But the shorter lead time changed the whole logic of the inventory. Because a buffer has to cover consumption over the order cycle and the lead time (StockM, TOC buffer zones), a few weeks of stock is now enough instead of several months. Products are ordered in smaller quantities and more often, and a change in demand can be answered with the very next order. According to the company, it has kept its circle of regular customers and attracted new ones, because shoppers know they’ll find what they need there.

This case shows that the margin vs turnover dilemma isn’t always solved with shelf prices. Sometimes it’s solved in purchasing. A cheaper supplier raises the margin per unit, but long deliveries force you to hold more stock and risk losing customers. A more expensive but closer supplier lowers the margin, but lets you hold less stock and serve customers more reliably. Which option is better isn’t shown by the unit price, but by gross profit in dollars, GMROI, and whether customers stay.

What can you do in practice, starting now?

  1. Separate the two situations. Overstock of good sellers and non-moving goods are different problems. For the first, it’s usually enough to stop ordering above the buffer; the second may need a discount.
  2. Before discounting, work out the sales growth you need. Use the formula above and judge whether that growth is realistic.
  3. Track GMROI alongside turnover. Turnover shows speed; GMROI shows whether that speed earns money.
  4. Weigh supplier discounts against time in the warehouse. Compare how much you save per unit with how much longer your money will be tied up.
  5. Set an end date for every promotion. And afterwards, check whether sales grew as much as you planned.
  6. Report recovered cash and profit separately. Management needs to know what came back once, what recurs, and what was a loss.

Frequently asked questions

Is higher inventory turnover always better?

No. Turnover can rise because of discounts that reduce gross profit, or because stock has been cut too far and the most important products start running short. Read turnover together with margin and availability.

What is GMROI and why is it useful?

GMROI shows how much gross profit each dollar invested in stock earns. It combines margin and turnover, so it helps you compare a product with a high margin that moves slowly against one with a low margin that moves quickly.

Is it worth taking a supplier discount for a larger quantity?

Sometimes. Compare the size of the discount with how much longer the extra goods will sit in the warehouse, what it will cost to hold them, and the risk that some won’t sell. If the extra quantity sells through in a few weeks, the discount may pay off. If it sits for months, it usually won’t.

Can I calculate these measures from my ERP?

Usually, yes. Margin, turnover, and GMROI need sales, cost of goods sold, and stock balances, which most ERPs hold. To see which part of your stock exceeds what’s needed, you need one more thing: a target stock level for each product at each location, calculated from its consumption and replenishment time. StockM provides this alongside your ERP, without replacing it (StockM system).

Does this apply to manufacturers?

Yes, for stocks of materials, components, and finished goods. The same margin and turnover calculations apply to finished goods (read more in Manufacturing).

Sources

  • StockM: Inventory and working capital: is inventory an investment for a business?
  • StockM: Where does working capital get tied up in inventory?
  • StockM: Buffer-based inventory management
  • StockM: Buffer zones of TOC in practice: green, yellow, red
  • StockM: TOC or forecasting: TOC dynamic buffer management should drive day-to-day inventory decisions
  • StockM: StockM system
  • StockM: wholesale and distribution, retail and perishable goods, manufacturing
  • ACCA: Ratio analysis
  • Shopify: GMROI: Gross Margin Return on Investment

The answer depends on how much gross profit each dollar invested in stock earns. A discount speeds up turnover only when sales grow enough to make up for the margin you give away. The other route is to speed up turnover without touching the price: stop ordering stock you don’t need to cover actual consumption and replenishment time. Turnover improves, and the margin stays where it was.

A discount is still the right call when you’ve already bought too much, and the goods won’t sell on their own. At that point, the question is no longer “margin or turnover”. It’s how much money you can still recover, and how quickly.

This article continues our series:

  • Inventory and working capital: is inventory an investment for a business?
  • Where does working capital get tied up in inventory?
  • How does managing inventory with dynamic buffers help release cash tied up in stock?
  • What are the most important inventory management KPIs?

Where does the dilemma of margin and turnover come from?

Most business owners know the situation. Cash is short, the warehouse is full, and finance wants inventory turnover to go up. The commercial team suggests the obvious fix: cut prices, run a promotion, clear out the stock. At the same time, purchasing argues that a bigger order with a supplier discount will improve the margin. Both arguments sound reasonable, but they pull in opposite directions.

One side wants to protect the profit on every unit sold. The other wants to protect the speed at which money comes back out of stock. To choose between them, you need a measure that captures both at once.

How are margin and turnover linked financially?

First, the terms. Gross profit margin is gross profit divided by sales revenue. ACCA calculates it like this (ACCA, Ratio analysis):

Gross profit margin = gross profit ÷ sales revenue × 100%

It’s important to keep margin and markup apart. Both are worked out from the same gross profit, just divided by different amounts. Say a product costs $60 and sells for $100. That leaves $40 of gross profit per unit.

Margin (on the selling price) = $40 ÷ $100 x 100% = 40%

Markup (on cost) = $40 ÷ $60 x 100% = 66.7%

The same $40 looks like two different numbers, so when purchasing talks about markup and finance talks about margin, they end up talking past each other, and their figures can’t be compared. Every formula in the rest of this article uses margin. If you plugged in markup instead, you’d get the wrong answer. For example, when working out how much more you need to sell after a 10% discount, a 40% margin gives +33%, but a 66.7% markup entered by mistake gives only +18%. The discount would look far easier to pay back than it really is.

Inventory turnover shows how quickly the money invested in stock comes back through sales. Expressed in days, it’s calculated like this (ACCA, Ratio analysis):

Inventory days = inventory ÷ cost of goods sold × 365

In financial analysis, a company’s return on capital is split into two parts: operating profit margin and asset turnover (ACCA, Ratio analysis). Put simply, your return depends on how much you earn on each sale and how many times a year the same money goes round.

ACCA gives this illustration: a 5% margin and an asset turnover of 2. That means every $100 of sales leaves $5 of profit, and every $100 invested generates $200 of sales a year. So $100 invested earns 2 × $5 = $10 a year, a 10% return. A 10% margin would give the same 10% return if the money went round only once a year. In other words, a lower margin can only be made up for by money turning over faster.

For inventory, the same logic is captured by GMROI (Gross Margin Return on Inventory Investment). It shows how much gross profit a company earns for every dollar invested in stock (Shopify, GMROI):

GMROI = gross profit ÷ average inventory at cost

The formula can be split into two parts:

GMROI = (gross profit ÷ sales) × (sales ÷ average inventory at cost)

GMROI = margin × inventory turnover on sales

When you cut the price, the first factor goes down. For GMROI not to fall, the second has to rise by more. The fact that turnover has improved tells you nothing about profit on its own.

How much do sales need to grow for a discount to pay off?

Before announcing a discount, it’s worth doing one calculation. If the price is cut by a given percentage, the increase in volume needed to keep gross profit the same is:

Required volume increase = price cut % ÷ (margin % − price cut %)

Current marginDiscountHow much more you need to sell
40%5%+14%
40%10%+33%
25%10%+67%
20%10%+100%

The calculation assumes the unit cost doesn’t change and the discount applies to the whole volume sold.

The lower the margin, the harder it is to pay for a discount with extra turnover. In wholesale and distribution, where margins are often thin, even a small discount needs a very large jump in sales. Whether that jump happens depends on how price-sensitive buyers are, on competitors, and on whether customers simply hold off until the next promotion.

Can you speed up turnover without cutting the margin?

Yes, and it’s often the cheaper route. Inventory turnover depends not only on how much you sell, but also on how much stock you hold. If sales stay the same and average inventory halves, turnover doubles and the margin doesn’t change.

As we wrote in Where does working capital get tied up in inventory?, overstock rarely builds up because of one big mistake. It comes from lots of small decisions: demand fell but replenishment carried on; safety stock stayed after the reason for it had gone; a supplier’s minimum order quantity or discount encouraged a bigger purchase; temporary stock became permanent. Each of these slows turnover, and later it seems the only way to speed it up again is a discount.

In TOC inventory management, every product at every location has a buffer: as much stock as is needed to cover actual consumption over the order cycle and the replenishment lead time (StockM, TOC buffer zones). On each ordering day, you order only what’s needed to top the buffer back up. Anything above the buffer simply isn’t reordered, and it turns back into cash through normal sales at the normal price. Dynamic Buffer Management (DBM) keeps these levels under review: if a product sits in the green zone for a long time, its buffer comes down; if it keeps dropping into the red zone, the buffer goes up.

That doesn’t remove the need for discounts. It changes their role: a discount becomes a tool for exceptions, not a standing way of correcting inventory mistakes.

When is a lower margin the right choice after all?

There are situations where cash today is worth more than margin tomorrow. The key is to recognize them and not to confuse them with routine replenishment.

  1. Slow-moving and non-moving goods. If a product has stopped selling, its cost is money already spent. The decision isn’t about what you paid for it, but about how much you can still recover and how quickly. The longer you wait, the less you can recover, while storage and handling costs keep adding up.
  2. Short shelf-life goods. Whatever isn’t sold before its expiry date is written off. A discount applied in time often means a smaller loss than a write-off.
  3. End of season and assortment exits. Once a season is over or a product is discontinued, the remaining stock may be worth much less next year, or nothing at all.
  4. A realistic, tested assumption about price sensitivity. Sometimes a discount really does lift sales enough. In that case, plan it as a promotion: with a goal, a start and end date, and a review afterwards.

How do you present the margin vs turnover choice to the board?

We covered the general financial points about inventory KPIs, such as why released cash comes back only once, in What are the most important inventory management KPIs?. Here we add three points that are specific to the choice between margin and turnover.

  • Compare dollars, not percentages. Margin and turnover often move in opposite directions, so each of them on its own can show an “improvement”. Base the decision on gross profit in dollars and on GMROI. In the example below, those are the figures that show which route actually earns more.
  • Convert a supplier discount into days in the warehouse. A discount for a larger quantity raises the margin per unit, but the extra goods sit in the warehouse for longer. Compare the discount in dollars with the extra inventory days it creates and what it costs you to hold that money: storage, financing, and the risk that some of the goods won’t sell.
  • Count the sales you miss at full price, too. The need for discounts often comes in a pair: overstock sits in the warehouse while best sellers are out of stock. When a product isn’t there, some full-price sales don’t happen or are put off. Cash released from overstock and moved into these products earns the full margin, not a reduced one.

Hypothetical example

The figures below are made up to show the calculation. This is not a client case. We assume the unit cost doesn’t change, storage costs are left out, and in scenario B the availability of the most important products stays the same.

A wholesale company sells a product with a unit cost of $60 and a selling price of $100. It sells 1,200 units a year. On average, it holds 400 units in the warehouse because the team habitually orders in large quantities. Finance asks for better turnover, and two routes are on the table.

  • Scenario A: discount. The price is cut by 10%, to $90. We assume sales rise by 20%, to 1,440 units, and ordering habits stay the same, so average stock remains at 400 units.
  • Scenario B: stock managed by buffer. The price stays the same. Only what’s needed to top up the buffer is ordered. We assume average stock falls to 200 units and sales stay at 1,200 units.
Measure (per year)Current situation: price $100Scenario A: sold at $90 all year (10% off)Scenario B: price $100, stock managed by buffer
Units sold per year1,2001,4401,200
Sales revenue$120,000$129,600$120,000
Cost of goods sold$72,000$86,400$72,000
Gross profit$48,000$43,200$48,000
Gross profit margin40%33.3%40%
Average inventory (at cost)$24,000$24,000$12,000
Inventory days12210161
GMROI2.01.84.0

Inventory days = average inventory ÷ cost of goods sold × 365. GMROI = gross profit ÷ average inventory at cost.

In scenario A, turnover improves: inventory days fall from 122 to 101. In a report, that would look like a success. But gross profit drops by $4,800, and GMROI falls from 2.0 to 1.8. To keep gross profit the same, the company would need to sell 1,600 units, a third more than now, not 20% more.

In scenario B, inventory days fall to 61, the margin is unchanged, and GMROI doubles. On top of that, once stock settles at the buffer level, the company recovers around $12,000 that was previously tied up in the warehouse, as a one-off. This cash comes back gradually, through normal sales, not all at once.

Now suppose the warehouse also holds 300 units of another product that has almost stopped selling. Their cost is $18,000. Sold at $70 each, they would bring back $21,000 and earn $3,000 of gross profit. If they can realistically be sold only at $50, the company would recover $15,000 in cash but book a $3,000 loss. In this case, a lower margin, even a negative one, can be the right decision, because the alternative is to wait and recover even less. What matters is making it clear to management that this is cash recovery, not profit growth.

Both cases point the same way. Speed up turnover on good sellers by cutting overstock, and save discounts for the products that won’t move without them.

How does this work in StockM?

StockM is an assortment and inventory management system built on TOC and Dynamic Buffer Management. Every product at every location is given a buffer that is adjusted to actual consumption, and on ordering day the system suggests the quantity needed to top the buffer up (StockM, Buffer-based inventory management). That way, overstock of good sellers comes down through normal sales, without changing the price.

Other features are directly linked to the balance between margin and turnover (StockM, Wholesale and distribution):

  • Supplier terms. Minimum order quantities, minimum order values, and delivery schedules can be set for each supplier individually, and purchase orders are built around these requirements. This shows where a buffer is being driven up by supplier terms rather than by demand.
  • Promotions and seasons. Buffers are raised temporarily for promotions and seasons, then returned to their previous level when the period ends. This stops promotional stock from lingering unnoticed in the warehouse. As we explain in TOC or forecasting, forecasts and commercial plans are needed when preparing for a promotion, but the outcome should be judged against actual consumption.
  • Assortment exits. Buffers for products being discontinued are reduced gradually, and reports help sell off the remaining stock in an orderly way.
  • Turnover reports. The system automatically produces SKU turnover reports, ABC analysis, and non-mover alerts, so non-moving products that may need a discount are spotted earlier.

StockM doesn’t make pricing decisions for the company. The system shows where stock exceeds what’s needed and which products have stopped moving, and the commercial and finance teams decide on any discount. The outcome also depends on data quality and on how the team acts on these signals.

StockM client: home, garden and yard tools retailer

The client’s name is not disclosed, and no figures are published.

The client sells home, garden and yard tools through three physical stores and an online store. Competition in this sector is fierce, so the company sourced most of its products from distant but cheaper suppliers. That was how it protected its margin.

This strategy came at a price. Because deliveries took several months, orders were large and inventory turnover was low. More importantly, the company couldn’t react quickly to changes in demand: if a product started selling better than expected, the next order would only arrive months later. Most of its customers were regulars, and if they couldn’t find what they needed, it was easy for them to go to competitors, namely the big retail chains.

After listening carefully to the challenges the company’s owners described and analyzing the state of its stock, we decided to change its supplier selection policy. Instead of distant, cheap suppliers, the company began to focus on more expensive but closer ones that could fulfill orders within one or two weeks.

The product margin did fall, of course. But the shorter lead time changed the whole logic of the inventory. Because a buffer has to cover consumption over the order cycle and the lead time (StockM, TOC buffer zones), a few weeks of stock is now enough instead of several months. Products are ordered in smaller quantities and more often, and a change in demand can be answered with the very next order. According to the company, it has kept its circle of regular customers and attracted new ones, because shoppers know they’ll find what they need there.

This case shows that the margin vs turnover dilemma isn’t always solved with shelf prices. Sometimes it’s solved in purchasing. A cheaper supplier raises the margin per unit, but long deliveries force you to hold more stock and risk losing customers. A more expensive but closer supplier lowers the margin, but lets you hold less stock and serve customers more reliably. Which option is better isn’t shown by the unit price, but by gross profit in dollars, GMROI, and whether customers stay.

What can you do in practice, starting now?

  1. Separate the two situations. Overstock of good sellers and non-moving goods are different problems. For the first, it’s usually enough to stop ordering above the buffer; the second may need a discount.
  2. Before discounting, work out the sales growth you need. Use the formula above and judge whether that growth is realistic.
  3. Track GMROI alongside turnover. Turnover shows speed; GMROI shows whether that speed earns money.
  4. Weigh supplier discounts against time in the warehouse. Compare how much you save per unit with how much longer your money will be tied up.
  5. Set an end date for every promotion. And afterwards, check whether sales grew as much as you planned.
  6. Report recovered cash and profit separately. Management needs to know what came back once, what recurs, and what was a loss.

Frequently asked questions

Is higher inventory turnover always better?

No. Turnover can rise because of discounts that reduce gross profit, or because stock has been cut too far and the most important products start running short. Read turnover together with margin and availability.

What is GMROI and why is it useful?

GMROI shows how much gross profit each dollar invested in stock earns. It combines margin and turnover, so it helps you compare a product with a high margin that moves slowly against one with a low margin that moves quickly.

Is it worth taking a supplier discount for a larger quantity?

Sometimes. Compare the size of the discount with how much longer the extra goods will sit in the warehouse, what it will cost to hold them, and the risk that some won’t sell. If the extra quantity sells through in a few weeks, the discount may pay off. If it sits for months, it usually won’t.

Can I calculate these measures from my ERP?

Usually, yes. Margin, turnover and GMROI need sales, cost of goods sold, and stock balances, which most ERPs hold. To see which part of your stock exceeds what’s needed, you need one more thing: a target stock level for each product at each location, calculated from its consumption and replenishment time. StockM provides this alongside your ERP, without replacing it (StockM system).

Does this apply to manufacturers?

Yes, for stocks of materials, components, and finished goods. The same margin and turnover calculations apply to finished goods (read more in Manufacturing).

Sources

  • StockM: Inventory and working capital: is inventory an investment for a business?
  • StockM: Where does working capital get tied up in inventory?
  • StockM: Buffer-based inventory management
  • StockM: Buffer zones of TOC in practice: green, yellow, red
  • StockM: TOC or forecasting: TOC dynamic buffer management should drive day-to-day inventory decisions
  • StockM: StockM system
  • StockM: wholesale and distribution, retail and perishable goods, manufacturing
  • ACCA: Ratio analysis
  • Shopify: GMROI: Gross Margin Return on Investment

Read more articles

  • Sandėlio valdymas, atsargų valdymas
    Lower margin or faster turnover? A practical financial dilemma
    Read more articles
  • Pagrindiniai atsargų valdymo rodikliai
    What are the most important inventory management KPIs?
    Inventory is “healthy” when the most important products don’t run short and no more money is invested in stock than actual consumption and replenishment time require. A single number won’t show you that. You need a set of KPIs that you read together: one that shows how much money is tied up in stock, another that shows whether customers get what they need, and a few more that show where something is going wrong with your inventory.
  • Atsargų valdymas įmonės sandėlyje
    How does managing inventory with dynamic buffers help release cash tied up in stock?
    Managing inventory with dynamic buffers frees up cash in a fairly simple way: you order only what current demand calls for. So if you have too much of a product, even one that sells well, you order only enough to last until the next replenishment. Every product at every location gets a target stock level that covers actual sales until the next delivery arrives. Anything above that level is simply not reordered. That stock sells over the following weeks, and the cash comes back with it. Any money you didn’t spend on ordering surplus stock is available straight away to order other products or to put toward other business goals.

Footer

Company requisites

UAB StockM
Kaštonų str. 24A, Giraitė,
Kaunas district, LT-54309
Lithuania

Company code: 301644556
VAT code: LT100003985813

Bank account: LT064010051005600389
Bank: Luminor Bank AS
Bank code: 40100
SWIFT: AGBLLT2X

Contact Us

LinkedIn
Facebook
Youtube

Sales

+370 687 08076
info@stockm.eu

Support

support@stockm.eu
StockM

Effective assortment management system based on Theory of Constraints (TOC).

  • Home
  • Company
  • News
  • Career
  • Contacts
  • Privacy policy

© 2026 · StockM